TY - JOUR
AU - Bell, David
AU - Eiser, David
AU - Phillips, David
PY - 2023
DA - January
TI - Stress testing the fiscal framework
JO - National Institute Economic Review
EP - 80
VL - 260
IS - 1
DO - https://doi.org/10.1017/nie.2022.20
AB - The part of the UK fiscal framework which determines how UK government funding is allocated across the four home nations has undergone profound change since 2012, given tax and social security devolution. The UK government's post-Brexit plans for regional development funding, state aid, regulation and trade negotiations have led to significant disagreements about the nature of the devolved fiscal and constitutional settlement. And the COVID-19 pandemic provided a major shock to a fiscal system with limited flexibility for the Scottish, Welsh and Northern Irish devolved governments. This paper reviews the changes and challenges faced during these reforms and policy shocks. We find that: tensions about reforms to funding arrangements reflect the inconsistency of principles guiding the reforms; that the UK government’s post-Brexit plans do reduce the policy autonomy of the devolved governments, but reflect powers central governments often have in even highly decentralised countries; and that temporary changes to rules and the nature of the COVID-19 pandemic prevented a subnational fiscal crisis, but that more systematic change may make the system more robust to future shocks. This suggests that a review of the principles underpinning the UK's subnational fiscal and economic policies would be highly worthwhile.
PB - Cambridge University Press
UR - https://strathprints.strath.ac.uk/83671/
KW - Coronavirus (COVID-19)
ER